|
Post by Beth on Mar 23, 2013 11:49:19 GMT -5
Tomorrow is the last of our Q&A sessions! This week at 4 pm GMT/12 noon EST it's your opportunity to ask Will any questions you have, whether they be about MSCSI, comics, academia or anything else.
Post your questions here.
|
|
|
Post by Beth on Mar 24, 2013 4:57:29 GMT -5
What were you hoping MSCSI would achieve when you came up with the idea and what do you think of the response it's had this far? Did you expect anything like this?
What advice would you give to someone who wants to get into writing comics?
|
|
|
Post by Beth on Mar 24, 2013 9:30:52 GMT -5
Some more!
We've seen photos of Suze and Sarah's workspaces. What does yours look like?
How did you go about writing the script? And how did you know how to structure it?
|
|
|
Post by Will on Mar 24, 2013 9:39:10 GMT -5
What were you hoping MSCSI would achieve when you came up with the idea and what do you think of the response it's had this far? Did you expect anything like this? I think I said somewhere, earlier in the process, that all I wanted for MSCSI was for it to provoke discussion, make people think a little and suggest a way of doing things. It achieved that almost before it had even launched, so everything else has been a bonus. I have been consistently surprised by how much MSCSI seems to touch people, but obviously I'm delighted. Individuals who have connected with Cat and her story have told us how much it means to them, to the extent that it's even inspired them, changed their approach to life and given them more confidence. I also said early on that I'd very much like to see young girls drawing Cat fan art and writing their own stories, and we have already seen some great MSCSI fan art and heard from 11 year old girls who love the first issue.
|
|
|
Post by Will on Mar 24, 2013 9:39:46 GMT -5
What advice would you give to someone who wants to get into writing comics? I haven't exactly broken into comics, so I'm not sure I am in the best position to advise anyone. My experience of MSCSI shows that you really can get your ideas circulating and seen by thousands of people, by making it into your own personal project and just seeing it through. But then, I am in a very privileged position with a lot of contacts and a professional profile, and a decent salary that I can afford to spend on artists and websites. So it would be ridiculous to assume anyone could just do the same thing if they had the energy, ideas and enthusiasm. I'm sorry that this isn't a very inspiring answer, but I think it would be wrong not to recognise the fact that I've got MSCSI out there to the public because society's cards are stacked in my favour, rather than because it's simply a good story. More positively, to anyone who wants to write, I would simply say, you have to write. You have to write badly, realise you are writing badly, write better, look back at your earlier work and be embarrassed by it, keep improving and keep writing. If you aren't embarrassed by what you wrote ten years ago, I would suggest you're doing something wrong.
|
|
|
Post by Will on Mar 24, 2013 9:40:51 GMT -5
We've seen photos of Suze and Sarah's workspaces. What does yours look like? My desk is a curious combination of digital and old-school. I often work between desktop computer, iPad and iPhone, sending notes to myself, but I also write a lot of things down on paper, using a pencil. I printed out the entirety of my last book, Hunting the Dark Knight, to proofread it, and now I am using the back of every page for scrap paper, working through it steadily. Often I find I get my best ideas when I am walking around or on a bus or train, so I frequently text myself or send myself brief shorthand messages from my phone, then paste them into a master document when I get home. I do most of my actual writing and emailing at a desktop, and most of my more casual browsing and social media on an iPad.
|
|
|
Post by Will on Mar 24, 2013 9:41:32 GMT -5
How did you go about writing the script? And how did you know how to structure it? I tend to visualise the pages in my head, and then break them down into panels, working out how many frames, of what size and in what arrangement we would need to tell the story in terms of clarity, rhythm, layout and so on. I do not see the pages as script -- I see them as finished pages. So the script is my attempt to convey what I'm seeing in my head to the artists. On a broader scale, I also juggle the mental sense of the pages visually in my head, so I can envisage how the reader will go from, for instance, a page with a number of small panels to a big, bold splash; or how many pages will work for a quieter scene of dialogue so it doesn't feel too rushed or too drawn-out; or what scene would make a good cliffhanger for the end of an issue. On an even bigger scale, I have a sense of where scenes, plot-lines, character trajectories and so on fit within the whole, right up to the level of the three-volume trilogy. The best way I can describe it is through the way Microsoft Word operates -- you can zoom in on a particular page or even part of a page, but you can also pull back to see 10 pages at once, or 100, and at different magnitudes you are seeing, and working on, different aspects, from micro patterns to macro patterns. You could also compare it to, for instance, zooming in tight on a detail to refine it in Photoshop, but also pulling back to check the composition of the whole image, within which that detail might be very tiny.
|
|
|
Post by Beth on Mar 24, 2013 9:46:23 GMT -5
What about MSCSI appeals to you most creatively?
I've been talking to you a lot about your 'voice' in various different texts. I think it pretty clearly comes through in MSCSI (the last panel on the first page, for example, if I'm remembering correctly) but what influences do you bring to the project in terms of style, characterisation and approach? Which artists do you most admire, and whose work inspires you most?
What would you most like to ask your readers/fans?
|
|
|
Post by Will on Mar 24, 2013 9:48:55 GMT -5
Here's a photo of my current work in progress. Attachments:
|
|
|
Post by Will on Mar 24, 2013 9:50:15 GMT -5
You can compare my writing in 2013 to my writing in 1978. Attachments:
|
|
|
Post by Will on Mar 24, 2013 9:51:08 GMT -5
What would you most like to ask your readers/fans? I'd like to know what they think will happen next: immediately next, and longer-term next.
|
|
|
Post by Will on Mar 24, 2013 9:51:59 GMT -5
I've been talking to you a lot about your 'voice' in various different texts. I think it pretty clearly comes through in MSCSI (the last panel on the first page, for example, if I'm remembering correctly) but what influences do you bring to the project in terms of style, characterisation and approach? I have been writing pretty much all my life, and I am no longer young, so I hope I do have some sort of style of my own by now -- and I think that whatever my 'voice' is probably comes across to an extent in MSCSI, as it does in my other work. I think the biggest single influence on MSCSI, in the early issues at least, was Neil Gaiman's 'A Game of You' storyline in Sandman. It's a very character-based, dialogue-heavy story -- I think he regards it as one of his 'female' stories -- and on a specific level, it's about a bunch of misfits living in a shared house in the 1990s. I was also a misfit living in a shared house in the 1990s, and I particularly enjoyed that story when I read it on its first publication. The fact that every character in 'A Game of You' has a secret, a dream-world, a special power or hidden history, is also pretty relevant to Dahlia Forrester's house in MSCSI. The early-to-mid-90s Vertigo titles were some of my favourite comics, and no doubt I am very much informed and influenced by the work of Grant Morrison on Doom Patrol, Animal Man and Kid Eternity, Peter Milligan on Shade and Enigma, Gaiman on Black Orchid and, prior to that, Gaiman's Violent Cases, Moore's Watchmen, Miracleman and Swamp Thing, Morrison's Zenith. That is the explicit feeling and aesthetic I was most trying to capture in MSCSI; superhero adventures that were woven with popular culture references -- alternative bands, cool fashions, little nods to news stories -- and had a sense of emotional resonance, a real weight and power to the characterisation and the dialogue. I am still haunted by moments in Doom Patrol -- I can still remember individual frames from Black Orchid and Enigma vividly. They are part of my personal history, like diaries, letters or favourite songs. Those stories, for me, were very moving and inspiring, while never rubbishing or forgetting the genre they belonged to. They were still superhero stories, written out of love for costumes, continuity, icons and secret identities -- they were just very good superhero stories. Sandman is part of the DC Universe, and all the richer for it.
|
|
|
Post by Will on Mar 24, 2013 9:52:39 GMT -5
What about MSCSI appeals to you most creatively? Seeing my prose is translated into a visual form is like magic. When you write fiction, obviously you have a visual in your head, and you have to try to put that across to the reader through words, essentially describing what you see and trying to get them to see it too. Comics are a similar process to film, in that they work through angles, lighting, performance and rhythm of shots, but you can achieve that final result much more quickly. It would take weeks, huge expense, a team of professionals and a great deal of organisation to film and edit the simple scene from issue 2 where Cat talks to Enrique in a coffee shop. Of course, it takes Suze and Sarah time and a lot of talent to draw and colour that scene, but I can see the end result far more quickly and easily than if we were working in TV or cinema. So the process of getting it from my head to a visual form is relatively fast, and extremely rewarding. There is a certain kind of pleasure in having your words interpreted and realised visually, and the process through which it becomes a collaboration, rather than just a literal splurge of your own thoughts onto a page. Suze and Sarah have added to my words, rather than just following instructions, and created something that is much more than the original script. Another interesting aspect is that, inevitably, the finished page doesn't look exactly as I originally imagined it, but by the time we're at that stage, I can never quite remember what I originally imagined. After years of various types of writing, including film scripts and fiction as well as many more traditionally scholarly works, I am starting to feel that perhaps comics may be my ideal creative form.
|
|
|
Post by Will on Mar 24, 2013 9:55:23 GMT -5
Here's some of my Batman book collection. Attachments:
|
|
|
Post by Beth on Mar 24, 2013 10:21:08 GMT -5
Those bookshelves are amazing! I am extremely jealous of your collection. There are some larger images over at the website too, if anyone would like to see those: www.mysocalledsecretidentity.com/communityI've got a couple more questions for you too (sorry!): How does working on MSCSI differ to working on an academic text (if it does at all)? What's been the hardest thing about working on MSCSI?
|
|