|
Post by Beth on May 19, 2013 11:28:33 GMT -5
Post your reactions here!
|
|
sophie_ali
Cat People
Twinkle Twinkle Little Bat, How I Wonder What You're At
Posts: 129
|
Post by sophie_ali on May 19, 2013 12:14:37 GMT -5
Urbanite hurt Cat’s arm, the big Meany! Still I like how Cat seems undeterred by his warnings. Very interesting developments this week. So now we know for sure that Grange and Stewart are not Urbanite and Misper but are just posing as them. I’ve been toying with the idea that as Grange Manor is a set then maybe Grange and Stewart are actors-for-hire. Still that makes me think that it’s too obvious. In that hiring actors would leave a paper trail which could reveal that Grange and Grange Manor is all a set. I still think that newspaper clipping is relevant. Maybe Urbanite or Grange is one of the people mentioned? (Someone faked their own death maybe?)- Wild speculation here I know I’ve also been thinking that some of the media was allowed into Grange Manor. Surely they would have realised it was a set? Maybe they’re part of the bigger plan to draw attention to the Manor and away from something else? I found it interesting that Misper was following Urbanite’s orders in getting information on Cat. I’d read it as Misper subverting Urbanite’s orders but it seems he was following them. This makes me think that their relationship is not quite as fragmented as I first thought. Although Misper seems a little uncomfortable with some of Urbanite’s actions, as seen from last week where he was fiddling with his cross. How did Urbanite come across Cat? Maybe Urbanite is someone closer to Cat than we actually think? Is the fact her Dad was a police officer relevant here. If Urbanite fights crime then he must have come across the actual law before (maybe her Dad is a bit like Gordon in Batman?). If this is the case then her Dad worked on the case in the newspaper clipping then, if Urbanite was also involved, then this provides a link somehow, if that makes sense because I’m really loosely speculating here! I find it interesting that Urbanite sent Misper to investigate Cat not himself. Maybe it’s due to Enrique being more her age or maybe Urbanite can’t risk his identity being found out (Cat worked out who Enrique was after all)- does this suggest Misper is more expendable than Urbanite? The first mind-map noted more than 1 Misper but Enrique denied it I think? I’m looking forward to what Cat’s investigations bring up!
|
|
|
Post by Beth on May 26, 2013 2:23:01 GMT -5
Very interesting developments this week. So now we know for sure that Grange and Stewart are not Urbanite and Misper but are just posing as them. I’ve been toying with the idea that as Grange Manor is a set then maybe Grange and Stewart are actors-for-hire. Still that makes me think that it’s too obvious. In that hiring actors would leave a paper trail which could reveal that Grange and Grange Manor is all a set.I'm not sure what they could be if they're not actors though... Unless they're former Mispers? (Assusming the other Mispers didn't actually get killed off.) I do think you're right that would leave a paper trail, but I can't think of any alternative at the moment. I do think you're right that the newspaper clipping in relevant. It's like Chekov's gun - if there's a gun in a drawer in the first act it'll be fired by the end of the third (or something like that!). It has to mean something. Thinking about newspaper articles and faked deaths though, I've now got this idea that Urbanite is actually Cat's dad - for some reason he faked his death (we don't really know what happened to him yet) and is now Urbanite. That would explain how he knows about Cat and why he sent Misper to follow her around. And if Misper knew who Urbanite was that would explain his discomfort with it. All wild speculation of course, but fun I find it interesting that Urbanite sent Misper to investigate Cat not himself. Maybe it’s due to Enrique being more her age or maybe Urbanite can’t risk his identity being found out (Cat worked out who Enrique was after all)- does this suggest Misper is more expendable than Urbanite? The first mind-map noted more than 1 Misper but Enrique denied it I think? Did you see Will's response to the last issue post? He seemed very cagey about there being more than one Misper... I think if they're all around the same age then that would suggest more than one, though the idea of them being expendable is actually pretty harsh when you think about it. Makes you wonder just how 'good' Urbanite is.
|
|
sophie_ali
Cat People
Twinkle Twinkle Little Bat, How I Wonder What You're At
Posts: 129
|
Post by sophie_ali on May 26, 2013 4:31:22 GMT -5
If this was the case then they could have a Luke Skywalker-Darth Vadar moment! ;D
That's what the proper name for it is! Thank you so much for writing that. I knew it had a proper name but I couldn't remember it. That's been bugging me for a couple of weeks now
I agree with you that Urbanite's morality seems to be called into question. Typically one could regard him as 'good' given that he's a superhero and thus aligned with 'justice' but he seems more morally complicated than that.
Even if his end goal is 'justice' (however you want to define that) I suppose we have to question to what means he is using to obtain that goal. If there is more than one Misper than is Urbanite willing to 'sacrifice' them for the greater good so to speak?
Like you said, it seems a little bit harsh. I'm reading Urbanite on a whole new level since the last few pages.
|
|
|
Post by Beth on May 26, 2013 15:39:22 GMT -5
RE: your last comment - me too! I think we're getting much more insight into Urbanite these past few pages. It's certainly interesting.
|
|